Peep Toe Dilemma

I have had these shoes forever and never wear them, because I do not like the way peep toes look on my feet.

I do adore the bow on the toe, LOVE is in the details folks, and the color- black, a classic.

But here is the real kicker- I have owned them for FOUR years and worn them THREE times.  Do I keep them? 

When I do wear them I like them, I just have trouble pairing them with a cute outfit.  Thinkin' they'd be cute with white capris and a red and black Polk-a-dot shirt? 

If only my actual style was as good as the style I have in my head.

Thoughts on these pumps?